Did Asteroid Impacts Provide Both the Heat and Raw Ingredients to Enable Life?

This is our Great Question: How did life begin on Earth? Anyone who says they have the answer is telling tall tales. We just don’t know yet.

While a definitive answer may be a long way off—or may never be found—there are some clever ways to nibble at the edges of that Great Question. A group of researchers at Kobe University in Japan are taking their own bites out of that compelling question with a question of their own: Did the heat from asteroid impacts help life get started?

This team of researchers is not the first to wonder about asteroid impacts and what role they may have played in the appearance of life on Earth. But rather than focus on asteroids impacting Earth and delivering water and chemicals, they’re looking at impacts between asteroids and other small bodies. It’s possible that the heat from those impacts generated water and life-origin chemicals on the asteroid’s surface, then delivered to Earth.

The group of scientists started with an asteroid proxy made of porous gypsum as a target. They placed thermocouples inside their asteroid to measure heat. Then they created high-velocity impacts by accelerating projectiles with Kobe University’s gas gun. Their two-stage gas gun is specialized physics equipment that can accelerate things to extremely high velocities.

On the left is the gas gun at Kobe University. Gas guns can propel projectiles at extremely high velocities for physics research. The image on the right is from a gas gun at a GM/Delco facility. It’s the result of a 7-gram plastic projectile fired from a gas gun at 7,000 meters per second into an aluminum block. Image Credits: (L) Yasui et al 2021, Kobe University. (R) By Camera Operator: R. D. Ward. Service Depicted: Other Service – ID: DDSC8513609, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=876520

A critical idea behind their experiment is aqueous alteration and the heat required to create it. Aqueous alteration is when minerals in rock change because of chemical reactions with water. Those reactions can create organic solids. But for those reactions to take place, there must be heat to melt the asteroid’s ice. In larger bodies, scientists think that the decay of Aluminum 26, a radioactive isotope, can provide heat for aqueous alteration. But that only occurs in larger asteroids of about 10km in diameter and may only have occurred in the Solar System’s first 10 million years or so before all of the Al 26 had decayed. Could aqueous alteration have occurred due to impacts on smaller asteroids much later into the Solar System’s life?

They monitored the temperature created by the impacts as they raised the velocity of their projectiles. They wanted to know not only how much heat was generated but how long that heat would persist. Could asteroid impacts create enough heat to create life-origin chemicals without destroying the asteroids themselves? How widespread are these conditions in the Solar System, and could these chemicals still be generated in older Solar Systems like ours?

In their paper, the team pointed out that in the main asteroid belt the relative velocity among asteroids is about 4 to 5 km/second. The shock of those collisions would’ve immediately raised the temperature around the resulting crater. Collisions like these were common in our Solar System’s youth, long after all of the Al 26 had decayed. The heat from these impacts would’ve been most pronounced on more porous asteroid bodies. There’ve been many numerical studies of the heat from these impacts, but the authors of this paper say theirs may be the first time they’ve been studied directly.

The researchers used different types of projectiles travelling at different velocities to develop a model of impact heating. The image below shows some of their experimental results.

The graph on the left shows impact results from a polycarbonate projectile travelling at 1.7?km?s?1. The graph on the right shows the impact results from an aluminum projectile travelling at 4.3?km?s?1. The points marked as i=1 through 4 represent the thermocouples. Image Credit: Yasui et al 2021.

With their experimental data in hand, the team developed a rule of thumb for the effects of impact heating on asteroids. The heat conduction model based on that rule allowed them to calculate the heat distribution around the impact crater. Then they compared their model against what is known about aqueous alteration and the formation of organic solids from analyses of meteorites.

This image shows heat distribution around the crater floor of asteroid parent bodies calculated using the Heat conduction model. The dotted lines are isotherm contour lines. The numbers that meet the isotherm contour lines indicate the value obtained when normalizing the distance from the impact point by the crater radius. Each panel shows results for objects at different distances from Earth. Image Credit: Yasui et al, 2021.

Overall, the researchers found that the potential for asteroid impacts to create chemicals necessary for life is more widespread than thought. It’s more widespread both spatially and temporally, and the necessary heat can be created from impacts that create craters as small as 100 m in diameter. The team says that their results increase the number of astronomical bodies that could have delivered water and organic substances for the origin of life on Earth.

Another interesting result of their work involves organic solids that originated in the nebular cloud at the very beginning of our Solar System’s formation. The team showed that the heat from impacts may be like a double-edged sword. Not only can that heat forge new organic materials, but it can destroy the same type of materials present on asteroids and asteroid parent bodies since the early days.

We may never know exactly what led to the appearance of life on Earth. But we can at least build a trail of evidence that leads to the necessities for it to appear. If this paper is correct in its conclusion, then the creation of some of the chemicals necessary for life might be more common than thought.

But that doesn’t mean life is.

The paper presenting these results is titled “Impacts may provide heat for aqueous alteration and organic solid formation on asteroid parent bodies.” It’s published in the journal Nature Communications Earth and Environment. The first author is Minami Yasui, lecturer at Kobe University’s Graduate School of Science.


Evan Gough

Recent Posts

Juno Reveals a Giant Lava Lake on Io

NASA's Juno spacecraft came within 1,500 km (930 miles) of the surface of Jupiter’s moon…

9 hours ago

What’s the Most Effective Way to Explore our Nearest Stars?

It was 1903 that the Wright brothers made the first successful self-propelled flight. Launching themselves…

16 hours ago

Radiating Exoplanet Discovered in “Perfect Tidal Storm”

Can tidal forces cause an exoplanet’s surface to radiate heat? This is what a recent…

22 hours ago

The Giant Planets Migrated Between 60-100 Million Years After the Solar System Formed

Untangling what happened in our Solar System tens or hundreds of millions of years ago…

1 day ago

Artemis Astronauts Will Deploy New Seismometers on the Moon

Back in the 1960s and 1970s, Apollo astronauts set up a collection of lunar seismometers…

2 days ago

Ice Deposits on Ceres Might Only Be a Few Thousand Years Old

The dwarf planet Ceres has some permanently dark craters that hold ice. Astronomers thought the…

2 days ago