Why Are Dying Stars in 47 Tucanae Cooling Off So Slowly?

The Hubble Space Telescope is going to be used to settle an argument. It’s a conflict between computer models and what astronomers are seeing in a group of stars in 47 Tucanae.

White dwarfs — the dying embers of stars who have burnt off all their fuel — are cooling off slower than expected in this southern globular cluster, according to previous observations with the telescope’s Wide Field Camera and Advanced Camera for Surveys.

Puzzled astronomers are now going to widen that search in 47 Tucanae (which initially focused on a few hundred objects) to 5,000 white dwarfs. They do have some theories as to what might be happening, though.

White dwarfs, stated lead astronomer Ryan Goldsbury from the University of British Columbia, have several factors that chip in to the cooling rate:

The Hubble Space Telescope. Image credit: NASA, tweaked by D. Majaess.

– High-energy particle production from the white dwarfs;

– What their cores are made up of;

– What their atmospheres are made up of;

– Processes that bring energy from the core to the surface.

Somewhere, somehow, perhaps one of those factors is off.

This kind of thing is common in science, as astronomers create these programs according to the best educated guesses they can make with respect to the data in front of them. When the two sides don’t jive, they do more observations to refine the model.

“The cause of this difference is not yet understood, but it is clear that there is a discrepancy between the data and the models,” stated the Canadian Astronomical Society (CASCA) and the University of British Columbia in a press release.

Since the white dwarfs are in a cluster that presumably formed from the same cloud of gas, it allows astronomers to look at a group of stars at a similar distance and to determine the distribution of masses of stars within the cluster.

“Because all of the white dwarfs in their study come from a single well-studied star cluster, both of these bits of information can be independently determined,” the release added.

You can read the entire article on the previous Hubble research on 47 Tucanae at the Astrophysical Journal.

Today’s announcement took place during the annual meeting of CASCA, which is held this year in Vancouver.


4 Replies to “Why Are Dying Stars in 47 Tucanae Cooling Off So Slowly?”

    1. Thank you. You’d make a wonderful savings-king. But a horrible fund raiser…lol.
      I read about 3/4ths of the info written in the PDF. I might be a novice, but I did understand parts of it. I am here to learn as much as I possibly can. Question: Isn’t our sun going to become a red giant then a white dwarf?

      1. Affirmative. The Sun will enter the red giant phase in about 5 billion years’ time, and then, after another billion years or so, it will have shed its outer shell to become a white dwarf. However, the Sun does not have sufficient mass to become a typical planetary nebula, but instead will just be a pale version of one.

Comments are closed.