Why Pulsars Are So Bright

When pulsars were first discovered in 1967, their rhythmic radio-wave pulsations were a mystery. Some thought their radio beams must be of extraterrestrial origin.

We’ve learned a lot since then. We know that pulsars are magnetized, rotating neutrons stars. We know that they rotate very rapidly, with their magnetic poles sending sweeping beams of radio waves out into space. And if they’re aimed the right way, we can “see” them as pulses of radio waves, even though the radio waves are steady. They’re kind of like lighthouses.

But the exact mechanism that creates all of that electromagnetic radiation has remained a mystery.

A team of researchers may have figured out how it all works. It has to do with gamma rays, electrons and positrons, and oscillating electric fields.

A new letter titled “Origin of Pulsar Radio Emission” presents these new results. The lead author of the paper is Alexander Philippov, an associate research scientist at the Flatiron Institute’s Center for Computational Astrophysics. The work is published in the American Physical Society’s Physics journal.

It all starts with the neutron star at the center of the pulsar.

When a massive star, between 10 and 29 solar masses, collapses and explodes as a supernova, it leaves a neutron star behind. A neutron star undergoes no further fusion, and becomes dominated by intense gravity. The powerful gravity overwhelms the atomic bonds in the star, crushing almost everything into neutrons. But the neutron star retains something important from its progenitor star: the rotational force.

Now, the neutron star has much less volume(and mass) than its progenitor, and like a figure skater who pulls their arms in while spinning, the spin rate increases. It’s called the “conservation of angular momentum,” a concept that comes up repeatedly in astronomy and astrophysics.

So now we have a neutron star that’s spinning hundreds of times a second. That rapid rotation creates very powerful electrical fields, the most powerful ones we know of, which tear electrons from the star’s surface. Those same fields accelerate those electrons to high velocities.

Schematic view of a pulsar. The sphere in the middle represents the neutron star, the curves indicate the magnetic field lines, the protruding cones represent the emission beams and the green line represents the axis on which the star rotates. Since the field lines are misaligned with the rotation axis, we see a pulsar as a rapidly flashing source of radio emission, if the magnetic poles are oriented twards Earth. Image Credit: By User:Mysid, User:Jm smits – Made by Mysid in Inkscape, based on en:Image:Pulsar schematic.jpg by Roy Smits., CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=2612701

The electrons are accelerated so powerfully that they emit gamma radiation. But the pulsar also has an extremely powerful magnetic field, and that field re-absorbs the gamma rays. That re-absorption produces another flood of plasma consisting of electrons and their anti-matter counterparts, positrons. That plasma then fills the magnetosphere.

“Photons produce pairs that radiate more photons that produce more pairs, leading to dense plasmas.”

Alice K. HArding, Astrophysicist, NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center.

In a pulsar, the magnetic fields are so strong, and the gamma-ray photons so energetic, that the production of electrons and positrons is extremely efficient. Physicists think that this can produce cascades of photons and electron-positron plasma. “Photons produce pairs that radiate more photons that produce more pairs, leading to dense plasmas,” writes Alice K. Harding in a commentary published in APS Physics. Harding is an astrophysicist at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center.

“These fields are so strong, and they twist and reconnect so violently, that they essentially apply Einstein’s equation of E = mc2 and create matter and antimatter out of energy,” said Professor Luis Silva at the Instituto Superior Técnico in Lisbon, Portugal, who was not involved in this study.

The blue dot in this image marks the spot of an energetic pulsar — the magnetic, spinning core of star that blew up in a supernova explosion. NASA’s NuSTAR discovered the pulsar by identifying its telltale pulse. Image Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SAO

But electrons and positrons are both charged particles, and they create their own electric fields that have a dampening effect on the pulsar’s electric field. The pulsar’s electrical field then gets so weakened that it begins to oscillate between negative and positive.

So now there’s a neutron star, with a powerful magnetic field, and a wobbling, oscillating electrical field. Those two fields interact, and the result are waves of electromagnetic energy sent out into space as radio waves. That only happens if the magnetic field and the electrical field are not aligned.

In this study, the researchers simulated these factors, and the energy produce by their simulations matches the energy observed from pulsars. In a press release, lead author Philippov compares the process to lightning, describing the radio wave emissions as “after-glow.”

“The process is a lot like lightning,” said study lead author Alexander Philippov. “Out of nowhere, you have a powerful discharge producing a cloud of electrons and positrons, and then, as an afterglow, there are electromagnetic waves.” A team of Japanese scientists discovered that lightning produces gamma rays and anti-matter in 2017.

Like pulsars, lightning can produce gamma rays and antimatter, too. Japanese scientists discovered this process in 2017. Image Credit: Kyoto University/Teruaki Enoto

There’s a caveat to this study, though. Even though the energy emitted by the team’s simulations matches the energy observed from pulsars, there’s a discrepancy. The particle energies in the simulations are much lower than in an actual pulsar. So even though the results are promising, there are some potential holes in it.

In her commentary on the work, Harding says that the team’s model “remains very much a “toy” model because it limits particle energies to values significantly lower than those of a real pulsar.” That’s not a condemnation, just an observation on the limitations of the model and its results.

Harding says there are questions that still need to be answered. “Are the pair-induced waves sufficiently bright to match observations? Can they escape the pulsar’s magnetosphere?” She also points out that this new work doesn’t explain other types of emissions emitted by the well-known Crab pulsar, and a few other pulsars.

A composite image of the Crab Nebula and Crab Pulsar (red dot in middle) showing the X-ray (blue), and optical (red) images superimposed. This new work can’t explain some of the emissions coming from the Crab Pulsar. Image Credit: By Optical: NASA/HST/ASU/J. Hester et al. X-Ray: NASA/CXC/ASU/J. Hester et al. – http://hubblesite.org/newscenter/newsdesk/archive/releases/2002/24/image/a, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=238064

This work is still a step forward, though. And the authors themselves know that their work must be scaled-up closer to real-world energy levels at a pulsar for their answer to be more robust.

Even as it stands, their work might create progress in a couple areas. Harding agrees with the team when they say that “Such a deeper understanding could help resolve the mysterious source of periodic bursts of radio waves, known as fast radio bursts, that emanate from neutron stars.”

An illustration of fast radio bursts in the night sky above CHIMES, the Canadian Hydrogen Intensity Mapping Experiment. Credit: James Josephides/Mike Dalley

These results might have implications for gravitational wave researchers, too. Those researchers use tiny fluctuations in pulsar timing to help detect gravitational waves.

“If you understand how the emission itself is produced, there’s a hope that we can also produce a model of the errors in the pulsar clock that can be used to improve pulsar timing arrays,” Philippov says.


Evan Gough

View Comments

  • "So now we have a neutron star that’s spinning hundreds of times a second. That rapid rotation creates very powerful electrical fields, the most powerful ones we know of, which tear electrons from the star’s surface. "

    There aren't any electrons in a neutron star. Is the some mechanism where a strong electric field can actually trigger beta decay?

Recent Posts

One of the Building Blocks of Life Can Form in the Harsh Environment of Deep Space Itself. No Star Required

In many ways, stars are the engines of creation. Their energy drives a whole host…

23 hours ago

Mars Might Have Lost its Water Quickly

Mars is an arid place, and aside from a tiny amount of water vapour in…

1 day ago

Gravitational lenses could be the key to measuring the expansion rate of the Universe

Nailing down cosmic expansion could depend on distant quasars, and the time it takes their…

1 day ago

Arecibo’s Damage is so Serious and Dangerous, They’re Just Going to Scrap the Observatory Entirely

In the wake of a second structural failure, the NSF has announced that the iconic…

2 days ago

A High Resolution, Cross-Eyed Look at the Entire Surface of Mars

A group of amateur and professional astronomers have collaborated to create what may be the…

2 days ago

Scientists Have Re-Analyzed Their Data and Still See a Signal of Phosphine at Venus. Just Less of it

The team that detected phosphine in Venus' atmosphere has reexamined the data and confirmed their…

4 days ago