Rising Temperatures Could Shut Down Plate Tectonics

Article written: 13 May , 2008
Updated: 24 Dec , 2015
by

Venus is known as the Earth’s twin, but a better name might be Earth’s “evil twin” planet. Although Venus has a similar size and mass to Earth, it has a dramatically different surface and atmosphere. And one of the biggest differences is that fact that Earth has plate tectonics, and Venus doesn’t. New research indicates that prolonged atmospheric heat might be able to shut down plate tectonics, and cause our planet’s crust to be locked in place. Don’t worry, this isn’t something we’ll have to worry about for a few hundred million years.

This research was done by scientists from the US, Canada and Australia, and published in this week’s edition of the journal Earth and Planetary Science Letters. According to the researchers, large amounts of volcanic activity or increases in the Sun’s luminosity could reach a tipping point, where the system of plate tectonics just shuts down.

Don’t worry, this isn’t an article about the dangers of global warming. The kind of temperatures we’re talking about here are beyond anything scientists are expecting from human-induced climate change.

These findings help explain why Venus might have evolved differently from Earth. Although the planet has a very similar size and geological makeup, the atmosphere on Venus is rich in carbon dioxide, and almost 100 times more dense. It acts like a blanket, trapping heat from the Sun, and raising temperatures to more than 450 °C.

Plate tectonics are very important for keeping our mild temperatures here on Earth. The carbon dioxide is pulled out of the air and trapped on the floor of the ocean. This carbon gets returned to the interior of the Earth when a free-floating sections of crust called tectonic plates slide underneath one another.

Scientists think that the Earth’s plate tectonics are stable and self-correcting, assuming excess heat from inside the Earth can escape through the crust. The flowing mantle keeps the tectonic plates moving.

But if the surface of the Earth is heated up for a long period of time, it could make the flowing mantle more viscous, so it stops flowing. This would shut down plate tectonics on Earth.

“We found the Earth’s plate tectonics could become unstable if the surface temperature rose by 38 °C (100 °F) or more for a few million years,” said lead author Adrian Lenardic, associate professor of Earth science at Rice University. “The time period and the rise in temperatures, while drastic for humans, are not unreasonable on a geologic scale, particularly compared to what scientists previously thought would be required to affect a planet’s geodynamics.”

One interesting discovery is that the rise in temperature doesn’t need to boil away the Earth’s oceans. The tectonic shut down could happen, even though there’s still liquid water on the surface of Earth.

Original Source: Rice University News Release


12 Responses

  1. Cynthia says

    I thought I read that Venus may have experienced catastrophic inversions of its crust in relatively recent terms. While that’s not tectonic plate action that would certainly be another worry!

  2. David says

    I read/saw the same study. If I remember correctly, the theory explains the relatively young appearance of Venus’ surface. The inversion is supposedly caused by the intense heat. Does this ring a bell with anyone else out there…

  3. Robert says

    Do we know that the core, or the mantle of Venus is molten?

  4. Astrofiend (Syd, Aust) says

    Hmmm – never heard of crust inversions. Catastrophic resurfacing through volcanism was the only theory I’d heard of (which seems likely), but no doubt someone has proposed an alternate explanation for the relatively young surface.

  5. pantzov says

    it’s good to have the debate started but this theory has a long way to go and much more research is needed to even begin taking it seriously.

    what sort of research was done? the article does not say so i am guessing it was a computer sim.

  6. NoAstronomer says

    What rationale is posited for increasing temperatures making the mantel *more* viscous?

    Crust inversion – sounds nasty.

  7. alphonso richardson says

    IF this theory’s correct, we could be screwed.

    Again

  8. Rusty says

    Glad to hear this isn’t yet ANOTHER global warming article, thanks….

  9. marcellus says

    AMEN! to Rusty.

  10. geokstr says

    I wonder if the fact that Venus is like, fifty MILLION miles closer to the sun has anything to do with its surface temperature. Or that, despite a lower gravity than Earth, the fact that it happens to have 90 times the atmospheric pressure might have something to do with its temperature. But no, it must be because the Venusians invented the first SUV’s billions of years ago.

  11. Edward says

    A temperature increase of 38° C is equivalent to 68.4° F, not 100° F (as stated in the quote). It would seem that the author incorrectly added the 32° F scale adjustment, which applies only when calculating exact (as opposed to relative) temperatures.

    1°F = 1.8°C
    y°F = 1.8 * x°C + 32

    While not a critical error, it is worthy of note.

  12. davey says

    I would say there are about 3 billion years of geologic history that says we should worry that much about it happening here.

Leave a Reply