≡ Menu

John Dalton’s Atomic Model

John Dalton, the father of atomic theory, by Charles Turner. Credit: Wikipedia

John Dalton, the father of atomic theory, by Charles Turner. Credit: Wikipedia

Atomic theory – that is, the belief that all matter is composed of tiny, indivisible elements – has very deep roots. Initially, the theory appeared in thousands of years ago in Greek and Indian texts as a philosophical idea. However, it was not embraced scientifically until the 19th century, when an evidence-based approach began to reveal what the atomic model looked like.

It was at this time that John Dalton, an English chemist, meteorologist and physicist, began a series of experiments which would culminate in him proposing the theory of atomic compositions – which thereafter would be known as Dalton’s Atomic Theory and would become one of the cornerstones of modern physics and chemistry. Dalton came up with this theory as a result of his research into gases. In the course of this research, he discovered that certain gases could only be combined in certain proportions, even if two different compounds shared the same common element or group of elements.

These experiments built upon two theories that had emerged near the end of the 18th century which dealt with chemical reactions. The first was the law of conservation of mass, formulated by Antoine Lavoisier in 1789, which states that the total mass in a chemical reaction remains constant – i.e. that the reactants have the same mass as the products.

The second was the law of definite proportions, first proven by the French chemist Joseph Louis Proust in 1799. This law states that if a compound is broken down into its constituent elements, then the masses of the constituents will always have the same proportions, regardless of the quantity or source of the original substance.

Studying these laws and building on them, Dalton developed his law of multiple proportions. This law states that if two elements can be combined to form a number of possible compounds, then the ratios of the masses of the second element, which combine with a fixed mass of the first element, will be ratios of small whole numbers.

In other words, elements combine at the atomic level in fixed ratios which naturally differ based on the compounds being combined, due to their unique atomic weights.

A depiction of the atomic structure of the helium atom. Credit: Creative Commons

A depiction of the atomic structure of the helium atom. Credit: Wikipedia/Creative Commons

The findings became the basis of of Dalton’s Atomic Laws or Model, which focuses on five basic theorems. The first states that elements, in their purest state, consist of particles called atoms. Second, the atoms of a specific element are all the same, down to the very last atom. Third, atoms of different elements can be told apart by their atomic weights. Fourth, atoms of elements unite to form chemical compounds. And finally, atoms can neither be created or destroyed in chemical reaction, only the grouping ever changes.

Dalton also believed atomic theory could explain why water absorbed different gases in different proportions – for example, he found that water absorbed carbon dioxide far better than it absorbed nitrogen. Dalton hypothesized this was due to the differences in mass and complexity of the gases’ respective particles.

In fact, it was this very observation that is believed to be the first time that Dalton hinted at the supposed existence of atoms. In the paper which addressed gas absorption in water, which was first published in 1805, he wrote:

“Why does not water admit its bulk of every kind of gas alike? This question I have duly considered, and though I am not able to satisfy myself completely I am nearly persuaded that the circumstance depends on the weight and number of the ultimate particles of the several gases.”

Dalton proposed that each chemical element is composed of atoms of a single, unique type, and though they cannot be altered or destroyed by chemical means, they can combine to form more complex structures (i.e. chemical compounds). This marked the first truly scientific theory of the atom, since Dalton reached his conclusions by experimentation and examination of the results in an empirical fashion.

Dalton’s also began studying atomic weights based on the mass ratios in which they combined, with the hydrogen atom taken as the standard. However, Dalton was limited by the crudity of his laboratory instruments and the fact that he did not conceive that the atoms of certain elements exist in molecular form, such as pure oxygen (O2).

He also believed that the simplest compound between any two elements is always one atom each. This was best illustrated in how he thought that the chemical formula for water was HO, not H2O.

Various atoms and molecules as depicted in John Dalton's A New System of Chemical Philosophy (1808). Credit: Public Domain

Various atoms and molecules as depicted in John Dalton’s A New System of Chemical Philosophy (1808). Credit: Public Domain

In 1803, Dalton orally presented his first list of relative atomic weights for a number of substances. This paper was published in 1805, but he did not discuss there exactly how he obtained these figures. In 1807, his method was revealed by his acquaintance Thomas Thomson, in the third edition of Thomson’s textbook, A System of Chemistry. Finally, Dalton published a full account in his own textbook, A New System of Chemical Philosophy, in 1808 and 1810.

The main flaw in Dalton’s theory – i.e. the existence of both molecules and atoms – was later corrected in principle in 1811 by Amedeo Avogadro. Avogadro proposed that equal volumes of any two gases, at equal temperature and pressure, contain equal numbers of molecules. In other words, the mass of a gas’s particles does not affect the volume that it occupies.

Avogadro’s law allowed him to deduce the diatomic nature of numerous gases by studying the volumes at which they reacted. Thus, Avogadro was able to offer more accurate estimates of the atomic mass of oxygen and various other elements, and made a clear distinction between molecules and atoms.

Alas, these and other discoveries both contradicted and refined Dalton’s theories. For instance, scientists have since discovered that the atom – once thought to be the smallest part of matter – can in fact be subdivided into even smaller elementary particles.

And whereas Dalton conceived as atoms as a single entity with no separation between positive, negative, and neutral charges, subsequent experiments by J.J. Thomson, Ernest Rutherford, and Neils Bohr revealed a more complex structure to the atom. These theories were later validated by observations made with the electron microscope. We also know that atomic weight is a product of the structure of the atoms themselves.

Hence, Dalton’s Atomic Model, in its purest form, is now only considered valid for chemical reactions. However, this does not diminish Dalton’s contribution to modern science.

Prior to his time, the atom was little more than a philosophical construct passed down from classical antiquity. Dalton’s groundbreaking work not only made the theory a reality but led to many other discoveries, such as Einstein’s theory of relativity and Planck’s quantum theory – two fields of study that form the basis of our modern understanding of the cosmos.

If you enjoyed this article there are others that you will enjoy on Universe today, such as an article that addresses the number or atoms in the universe, or another on dark matter.

If you want to learn more about Dalton’s model, check out the article from Central Queensland University that goes into detail about Dalton’s Atomic model, or the article on the Clackham Community College website that explains the theory in the brief.

You can also check out Astronomy Cast Episode 138: Quantum Mechanics which goes into detail about the subject of Quantum physics.

Additional info:
Wikipedia – John Dalton
Wise Geek
Chemical Heritage Foundation


Matt Williams is the Curator of the Guide to Space for Universe Today, a a regular contributor to HeroX, a science fiction author, and a Taekwon-Do instructor. He lives with his family on Vancouver Island in beautiful BC.

Comments on this entry are closed.