Categories: NeptuneUranus

Giant Balls of Mush Made From Ammonia and Water Form in the Atmospheres of Uranus and Neptune

One advantage to planetary science is that insights from one planet could explain phenomena on another.  We understand Venus’ greenhouse gas effect from our own experience on the Earth, and Jupiter and Saturn share some characteristics.  But Jupiter also provides insight into other, farther out systems, such as Uranus and Neptune.  Now, a discovery from a spacecraft orbiting Jupiter might have solved a long-standing mystery about Uranus and Neptune – where has all the ammonia gone?

Scientists have long noticed an absence of ammonia in the atmospheres of Uranus and Neptune when compared to the amounts seen on Jupiter and Saturn.  Many considered that fact strange as planetary formation models suggested that all gas giants originated from the same “primordial soup,” so their compositions should be similar.  Theories abounded as to where the ammonia had gone, but a closer inspection of Jupiter itself hints at a potential explanation.

Composite image of the gas giants.
Credit – Jupiter from Juno: NASA/SwRI/MSSS/Gerald Eichstädt/Seán Doran; Saturn from Cassini: NASA/JPL-Caltech/Space Science Institute; Uranus and Neptune from HST: NASA/ESA/A. Simon (NASA Goddard Space Flight Center), and M.H. Wong and A. Hsu (University of California, Berkeley).

Juno, a probe that is currently exploring the Jupiter system, noticed that ammonia in the upper atmosphere formed “mushballs” by merging with water also present in the atmosphere.  Like hailstones, these mushballs are more liquid than traditional hailstones, as the ammonia liquefies water comes into contact with even at extremely low temperatures, such as those found in Jupiter’s upper atmosphere.

These amalgamated mushballs can grow to be bigger than some of the more giant hailstones on Earth.  They are also prone to rapidly falling through the atmosphere, dragging their constituent parts down out of the upper reaches of the atmosphere.  As they get closer to the center of Jupiter, the temperature rises, vaporizing the ammonia and water and allowing them to climb back towards the observable upper reaches.

The ammonia mushball cycle as seen on Jupiter.
Credit: NASA / JPL – Caltech / SwRI / CNRS

According to Tristan Guillot of the CRNS Laboratoire Lagrange, the same process might be happening on Neptune and Uranus, but the mushballs hold the ammonia down in the lower atmosphere for longer, without as much chance of releasing it back up to observable altitudes.   

At such low altitudes, the ammonia would appear to be missing with current observational capabilities.  The upper layers of clouds would obscure any ammonia reading, making it appear as if it vanished.  

UT video discussing the exploration of Uranus and Neptune.

To see the vanished ammonia would require a dedicated mission specifically to explore the lower atmospheres of the outer planets.  Some missions have been touted in the past, but none are currently operational.  As Dr. Guillot points out, understanding the outer planets in our own solar system would help us understand the atmospheres of exoplanets far beyond our own solar system.  Perhaps it is time to send a dedicated probe out to learn more about our farthest out planetary neighbors.

Learn More:
EuroPlanet Society – Mushballs stash away missing ammonia at Uranus and Neptune
EarthSky – Mushballs explain missing ammonia on ice giants
AGU – Storms and the Depletion of Ammonia in Jupiter: I. Microphysics of “Mushballs”
UT – Ammonia Key to Titan’s Atmosphere

Lead Image:
Artist’s depiction of a mushball in a gas giant’s atmosphere.
Credit – NASA/JPL-Caltech/SwRI/CNRS

Andy Tomaswick

Recent Posts

Hot Stars Blast Away at gas Giants Until Only Their Rocky Cores Remain

We don't see many Neptune-sized worlds closely orbiting their star. That may be because the…

21 hours ago

JWST’s Science, Surgeon Robot for ISS, Booster 7 Test Fire

James Webb delivers scientific results, SLS and Starship go closer to their maiden flights, remote…

23 hours ago

MIT Researchers Propose Space Bubbles to Stop Climate Change

Climate change is a real problem. Human caused outputs of greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide…

1 day ago

In Wildly Different Environments, Stars End Up Roughly the Same

When you look at a region of the sky where stars are born, you see…

1 day ago

Primordial Black Holes Could Have Triggered the Formation of Supermassive Black Holes

Computer simulations show the role primordial black holes may have played in the early universe,…

2 days ago

Why Betelgeuse Dimmed

Using data from Hubble and other observatories, a team of scientists have determine the cause…

3 days ago