Comet Y4 ATLAS Breaks Up…Enter Comet F8 SWAN

When it comes to comets, the only thing that is certain is the orbital path. Though the cosmos has yet to send us a really bright comet for 2020 to keep us occupied during the ongoing worldwide pandemic and lock down, it has sent us a steady stream of descent binocular comets, including C/2017 T2 PanSTARRS, C/2019 Y1 ATLAS, and C/2019 Y4 ATLAS. And though Y4 ATLAS won’t match the “Comet of the Century” media hype, another interesting binocular comet has just made its presence known over the past weekend: C/2020 F8 SWAN.

Comet Y4 ATLAS from April 11th, showing a fragmented, elongated nucleus. Credit: Gianluca Masi and the Virtual Telescope Project.

Comet Y4 ATLAS broke its over-performing trend early last week, disintegrating into several fragments as observers watched on. This is not uncommon, especially as a comet nears the Sun. We all remember the painful saga of C/2012 S1 ISON on U.S. Thanksgiving Day 2013. Astronomer Karl Battams at the U.S. Naval Research Laboratory called it back in mid-March, stating “I still worry that this comet is not entirely happy with the conditions it’s facing, and might fizzle out,” on Twitter.

Comet Y4 ATLAS shedding fragments from April 10th. Credit: Efrain Morales Rivera.

And as is also common with new comets, Y4 ATLAS became the center of a lot of unwarranted hype prior to breakup, with many news outlets exclaiming that it could become a “great daylight comet as bright as the Moon” (spoiler alert: it won’t). Some of this stemmed from the comet’s brightening ahead of predictions in March, and its orbital similarities and probable relation to the Comet of 1844.

Y4 ATLAS broke up 1.4 Astronomical Units (AU) from the Sun as it was crossing the constellation Camelopardalis. Already, its brightness has taken a hit, fading a full magnitude down to +8.5. It remains to be seen if we’ll have anything left to recover during this May’s dawn apparition of the comet, but prospects aren’t good.

Enter Comet SWAN

But the cosmos has another cometary card up its sleeve. Rumors abounded this past weekend of an already bright comet found approaching from sunward spotted by a solar observing spacecraft. This is not an unusual occurrence; for example, Comet C/1948 V1 was actually discovered by surprised ground observers during a total solar eclipse while it was near the Sun at an already bright magnitude -2.

Comet C/2020 F8 SWAN from April 11th. Image credit: Remanzacco Observatory.

The Minor Planet Center at Harvard finally released circular 2020-G94 on Sunday night, announcing the discovery of Comet C/2020 F8 SWAN. The comet was discovered in March 25th images from the SWAN (the Solar Wind ANisotropies) camera aboard the Solar Heliospheric Observer (SOHO) spacecraft.

F8 SWAN was discovered while it was deep in the southern hemisphere skies at 1.77 AU distant. Currently shining at magnitude +8 in the constellation of Grus the Crane, the comet will pass closest to the Earth at 0.556 AU (51.7 million miles) distant on May 13th , moving about two degrees (four times the diameter of the Full Moon) a day. The comet then reaches perihelion shortly afterwards on May 27th.

It seems like we either caught first sight of the comet in outburst, and/or it’s an intrinsically large bright object, another plus.

The path of comet F8 SWAN through the inner solar system. Credit:

With a steep orbit inclined 111 degrees relative to the ecliptic plane, Comet F8 SWAN is on an orbit in access of 10,000 years. The comet could also be making its first visit to the inner solar system, meaning its dynamically new and prone to lots of outbursts as it nears the warmth of the inner solar system for the first time.

For northern hemisphere observers at mid-latitudes, the very best time to catch this comet is in mid-to late May, low to the northeast at dawn. Ironically, the comet will greet what remains of Comet Y4 ATLAS in the same region of sky on May 22nd.

The projected light curve for Comet F8 SWAN. Credit: Adapted from Seiichi Yoshida’s Weekly Information About Bright Comets.

Here’s our look at dates with celestial destiny this Spring for Comet F8 SWAN:


(Unless otherwise noted: a close pass is one degree or less)

16-Crosses into the constellation Sculptor

18-Passes +4.4 magnitude Gamma Sculptoris

23-Passes 18 degrees from the southern galactic pole

26-crosses into the constellation Aquarius the Water-Bearer

30-Passes into the constellation Cetus

The celestial path of Comet F8 SWAN through May. Credit: Starry Night Education Software.


1-May break +6th magnitude

4-Passes +3.5 magnitude Iota Ceti

5-Nicks the corner of the constellation of Pisces the Fishes

6-Crosses back into the constellation of Cetus the Whale

7-Crosses the celestial equator northward

8-Crosses back into the constellation Pisces

9-Crosses the ecliptic northward

12-Photo-op: passes 2 degrees from +3.4 magnitude Eta Piscium and the galaxy Messier 74

13-Passes closest to Earth at 0.556 AU (51.7 million miles) distant

14-Nicks the corner of the constellation of Aries the Ram

15-Crosses into the constellation Triangulum

16-Photo op: passes 6 degrees from galaxy Messier 33

17-May top out at +4th magnitude

18-Crosses into the constellation Perseus

19-Passes +4.2 magnitude 16 Persei

20-Passes 14’ from +2 magnitude Algol

22-Passes 5 degrees from Comet Y4 ATLAS

26-Reaches its farthest point north (declination +46 degrees)

27-Reaches perihelion at 0.429 AU (39.9 million miles) from the Sun

29-Crosses the galactic plane northward

30-Crosses into Auriga

The path of Comet F8 SWAN through May into early June at dawn looking to the northeast from latitude 35 degrees north. Credit: Starry Night Education Software.


1-Passes near Capella

15-May drop back below +6th magnitude

16-Passes +2.6 magnitude Theta Auriga

29-Passes less than 10 degrees from the Sun

30-Drops below +10th magnitude

One can only imagine the spectacle of two bright comets at dawn. Remember waaaay back when in the late 90s, when comets Hyakutake and Hale-Bopp graced northern skies in rapid-fire succession? It can be argued that we’ve yet to have a very bright northern hemisphere comet since the advent of digital astrophotography. Gambler’s fallacy notwithstanding, we’re due.

If there’s an onus you can assign to the Universe, it seems to be mocking us, with no solar activity, no meteor showers and no eclipse to keep stay-at-home astronomers and skywatchers occupied. Perhaps, tracking down this current string of binocular comets will prove to be a worthy pursuit.

What could have been… a (highly optimistic) view of Comets Y4 ATLAS meeting up with F8 SWAN at dawn. Credit: Starry Night Education Software

Lead image: Newly discovered Comet C/2020 F8 SWAN, imaged using the remote Q56 Telescope Live in Australia. Image credit: E. Guido, M. Rocchetto, and A. Valvasori.

One Reply to “Comet Y4 ATLAS Breaks Up…Enter Comet F8 SWAN”

Comments are closed.