If We Want to Visit More Asteroids, We Need to Let the Spacecraft Think for Themselves

Missions to asteroids have been on a tear recently. Visits by Rosetta, Osirix-REX, and Hayabusa2 have all visited small bodies and, in some cases, successfully returned samples to the Earth. But as humanity starts reaching out to asteroids, it will run into a significant technical problem – bandwidth. There are tens of thousands of asteroids in our vicinity, some of which could potentially be dangerous. If we launched a mission to collect necessary data about each of them, our interplanetary communication and control infrastructure would be quickly overwhelmed. So why not let our robotic ambassadors do it for themselves – that’s the idea behind a new paper from researchers at the Federal University of São Paulo and Brazil’s National Institute for Space Research.

The paper primarily focuses on the control problem of what to do when a spacecraft is approaching a new asteroid. Current missions take months to approach and require consistent feedback from ground teams to ensure the spacecraft understands the parameters of the asteroid it’s approaching – especially the gravitational constant.

Some missions have seen more success with that than others – for example, Philase, the lander that went along with Rosetta, had trouble when it bounced off the surface of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko. As the authors pointed out, part of that difference was a massive discrepancy between the actual shape of the comet and the observed shape that telescopes had seen before Rosetta arrived there. 

Fraser discusses the possibility of capturing an asteroid.

Even more successful missions, such as OSIRIS-Rex, take months of lead-up time to complete relatively trivial maneuvers in the context of millions of kilometers their overall journey takes them. For example, it took 20 days for OSIRIX-Rex to perform multiple flybys at 7 km above the asteroid’s surface before its mission control deemed it safe to enter a stable orbit.

One of the significant constraints the mission controllers were looking at was whether they could accurately calculate the gravitational constant of the asteroid they were visiting. Gravity is notoriously difficult to determine from far away, and its miscalculation led to the problems with Philae. So, can a control scheme do to solve all of these problems?

Simply put, it can allow the spacecraft to decide what to do when approaching their target. With a well-defined control scheme, the likelihood of a spacecraft failure due to some unforeseen consequence is relatively minimal. It could dramatically decrease the time missions spend on approach and limit the communication bandwidth back toward mission control on Earth. 

One use case for quick asteroid mission – mining them, as Fraser discusses here.

Such a scheme would also require only four relatively ubiquitous, inexpensive sensors to operate effectively – a LiDAR (similar to those found on autonomous cars), two optical cameras for depth perception, and an inertial measurement unit (IMU) that measures parameters like orientation, acceleration, and magnetic field. 

The paper spends plenty of time detailing the complex math that would go into the control schema – some of which involve statistical calculations similar to basic learning models. The authors also run trials on two potential asteroid targets of interest to see how the system would perform.

One is already well understood. Bennu was the target of the OSIRIX-Rex mission and, therefore, is well-characterized as asteroids go. According to the paper, with the new control system, a spacecraft could enter a 2000 m orbit within a day of approaching from hundreds of kilometers away, then enter an 800 m orbit the next day. This is compared to the months of preparatory work the actual OSIRIS-Rex mission had to accomplish. And it can be completed with minimal thrust and, more importantly, fuel – a precious commodity on deep-space missions.

Asteroid defense is another important use case for quick asteroid missions – as Isaac Arthus discusses in this video.
Credit – Isaac Arthur

Another demonstration mission is one to Eros, the second-largest asteroid near Earth. It has a unique shape for an asteroid, as it is relatively elongated, which could pose an exciting challenge for automated systems like those described in the paper. Controlling a spacecraft with the new schema for a rendezvous with Eros doesn’t have all the same advantages of a more traditional asteroid like Bennu. For example, it has a much higher thrust requirement and fuel consumption. However, it still shortens the mission time and bandwidth required to operate it.

Autonomous systems are becoming increasingly popular on Earth and in space. Papers like this one push the thinking about what is possible forward. Suppose all that’s required to eliminate months of painstaking manual technical work is to slap a few sensors and implement a new control algorithm. In that case, it’s likely that one of the various agencies and companies planning to rendezvous with an asteroid shortly will adopt that plan.

Learn More:
Negri et al. – Autonomous Rapid Exploration in Close-Proximity of an Asteroid
UT – Miniaturized Jumping Robots Could Study An Asteroid’s Gravity
UT – How to Make Asteroid Landings Safer
UT – A Spacecraft Could use Gravity to Prevent a Dangerous Asteroid Impact

Lead Image:
Artist’s conception of the Lucy mission to the Trojan asteroids.
Credit – NASA

Andy Tomaswick

Recent Posts

Fish Could Turn Regolith into Fertile Soil on Mars

What a wonderful arguably simple solution. Here’s the problem, we travel to Mars but how…

1 day ago

New Simulation Explains how Supermassive Black Holes Grew so Quickly

One of the main scientific objectives of next-generation observatories (like the James Webb Space Telescope)…

1 day ago

Don't Get Your Hopes Up for Finding Liquid Water on Mars

In the coming decades, NASA and China intend to send the first crewed missions to…

2 days ago

Webb is an Amazing Supernova Hunter

The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has just increased the number of known distant supernovae…

2 days ago

Echoes of Flares from the Milky Way’s Supermassive Black Hole

The supermassive black hole at the heart of our Milky Way Galaxy is a quiet…

3 days ago

Warp Drives Could Generate Gravitational Waves

Will future humans use warp drives to explore the cosmos? We're in no position to…

3 days ago