≡ Menu

Opportunity Discovers Most Powerful Evidence Yet for Martian Liquid Water

Opportunity discovers Water related mineral vein at Endeavour Crater - November 2011
Opportunity rover discovered Gypsum at the Homestake mineral vein, while exploring around the base of Cape York ridge at the westerm rim of Endeavour Crater. The vein is composed of calcium sulfate and indicates the ancient flow of liquid water at this spot on Mars. Opportunity drove North (ahead) from here in search of a sunny winter haven. This panoramic mosaic of images was taken on Sol 2761, November 2011, and illustrates the exact spot of the mineral vein discovery.
Credit: NASA/JPL/Cornell/Kenneth Kremer/Marco Di Lorenzo
click to enlarge
Published on Astronomy Picture of the Day (APOD): 12 Dec 2011
http://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap111212.html

NASA’s long lived Opportunity rover has discovered the most scientifically compelling evidence yet for the flow of liquid water on ancient Mars. The startling revelation comes in the form of a bright vein of the mineral gypsum located at the foothills of an enormous crater named Endeavour, where the intrepid robot is currently traversing. See our mosaic above, illustrating the exact spot.

Update: ‘Homestake’ Opportunity Mosaic above has just been published on Astronomy Picture of the Day (APOD) – 12 Dec 2011 (by Ken Kremer and Marco Di Lorenzo)

Researchers trumpeted the significant water finding this week (Dec. 7) at the annual winter meeting of the American Geophysical Union (AGU) in San Francisco.

“This gypsum vein is the single most powerful piece of evidence for liquid water at Mars that has been discovered by the Opportunity rover,” announced Steve Squyres of Cornell University, Ithaca, N.Y., Principal Investigator for Opportunity, at an AGU press conference.

The light-toned vein is apparently composed of the mineral gypsum and was deposited as a result of precipitation from percolating pools of liquid water which flowed on the surface and subsurface of ancient Mars, billions of years ago. Liquid water is an essential prerequisite for life as we know it.

“This tells a slam-dunk story that water flowed through underground fractures in the rock,” said Squyres. “This stuff is a fairly pure chemical deposit that formed in place right where we see it. That can’t be said for other gypsum seen on Mars or for other water-related minerals Opportunity has found. It’s not uncommon on Earth, but on Mars, it’s the kind of thing that makes geologists jump out of their chairs.”

'Homestake' Vein in Color and Close-up
This color view of a mineral vein called "Homestake" was taken by the panoramic camera (Pancam) on NASA's Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity. The vein is about the width of a thumb and about 18 inches (45 centimeters) long. Opportunity examined it in November 2011 and found it to be rich in calcium and sulfur, possibly the calcium-sulfate mineral gypsum.

The light-toned vein is informally named “Homestake”, and was examined up close by Opportunity’s cameras and science instruments for several weeks this past month in November 2011, as the rover was driving northwards along the western edge of a ridge dubbed ‘Cape York’ – which is a low lying segment of the eroded rim of Endeavour Crater.

Veins are a geologic indication of the past flow of liquid water

Opportunity just arrived at the rim of the 14 mile (22 kilometere) wide Endeavour Crater in mid-August 2011 following an epic three year trek across treacherous dune fields from her prior investigative target at the ½ mile wide Victoria Crater.

“It’s like a whole new mission since we arrived at Cape York,” said Squyres.

‘Homestake’ is a very bright linear feature.

“The ‘Homestake’ vein is about 1 centimeter wide and 40 to 50 centimeters long,” Squyres elaborated. “It’s about the width of a human thumb.”

Opportunity's Approach to 'Homestake'
This view from the front hazard-avoidance camera on NASA's Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity shows the rover's arm's shadow falling near a bright mineral vein informally named Homestake. The vein is about the width of a thumb and about 18 inches (45 centimeters) long. Opportunity examined it in November 2011 and found it to be rich in calcium and sulfur, possibly the calcium-sulfate mineral gypsum. Opportunity took this image on Sol 2763 on Mars (Nov. 7, 2011). Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech

Homestake protrudes slightly above the surrounding ground and bedrock and appears to be part of a system of mineral veins running inside an apron (or Bench) that in turn encircles the entire ridge dubbed Cape York.

In another first, no other veins like these have been seen by Opportunity throughout her entire 20 miles (33 kilometers) and nearly eight year long Martian journey across the cratered, pockmarked plains of Meridiani Planum, said Squyres.

The veins have also not been seen in the higher ground around the rim at Endeavour crater.

“We want to understand why these veins are in the apron but not out on the plains,” said the mission’s deputy principal investigator, Ray Arvidson, of Washington University in St. Louis. “The answer may be that rising groundwater coming from the ancient crust moved through material adjacent to Cape York and deposited gypsum, because this material would be relatively insoluble compared with either magnesium or iron sulfates.”

Opportunity was tasked to engage her Microscopic Imager and Alpha Particle X-ray Spectrometer (APXS) mounted on the terminus of the rover’s arm as well as multiple filters of the mast mounted Panoramic Camera to examine ‘Homestake’.

“The APXS spectrometer shows ’Homestake’ is chock full of Calcium and Sulfur,” Squyres gushed.

Microscopic Close-up View of 'Homestake' Vein
This close-up view of a mineral vein called Homestake comes from the microscopic imager on Opportunity. The vein is about the width of a thumb and about 18 inches (45 centimeters) long. Opportunity examined it in November 2011 and found it to be rich in calcium and sulfur, possibly the calcium-sulfate mineral gypsum. Homestake is near the edge of the "Cape York" segment of the western rim of Endeavour Crater. This view blends three exposures taken by the microscopic imager during the 2,765th and 2,766th Martian days, or sols, of Opportunity's career on Mars (Nov. 3 and 4, 2011). Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/Cornell/USGS

The measurements of composition with the APXS show that the ratio points to it being relatively pure calcium sulfate, Squyres explained. “One type of calcium sulfate is gypsum.”

Calcium sulfate can have varying amounts of water bound into the minerals crystal structure.

The rover science team believes that this form of gypsum discovered by Opportunity is the dihydrate; CaSO4•2H2O. On Earth, gypsum is used for making drywall and plaster of Paris.

The gypsum was formed in the exact spot where Opportunity found it – unlike the sulfate minerals previously discovered which were moved around by the wind and other environmental and geologic forces.

“There was a fracture in the rock, water flowed through it, gypsum was precipitated from the water. End of story,” Squyres noted. “There’s no ambiguity about this, and this is what makes it so cool.”

At Homestake we are seeing the evidence of the ground waters that flowed through the ancient Noachian rocks and the precipitation of the gypsum, which is the least soluble of the sulfates, and the other magnesium and iron sulfates which Opportunity has been driving on for the last 8 years.

Opportunity Traverse Map 2004 to 2011
Traverse map showing the 8 Year Journey of Opportunity from Eagle Crater landing site Sol 1 (Jan. 24, 2004) to Sol 2775 (November 2011). Map shows rover location around Homestake water related mineral on Sol 2763 (November 2011) at Cape York ridge at Endeavour Crater rim. Endeavour Crater is 14 miles or 22 kilometers in diameter. Opportunity has driven more than 21 miles (34 km).
Credit: NASA/JPL/Cornell/Marco Di Lorenzo/Kenneth Kremer

“Here, both the chemistry, mineralogy, and the morphology just scream water,” Squyres exclaimed. “This is more solid than anything else that we’ve seen in the whole mission.”

It’s inconceivable that the vein is something else beside gypsum, said Squyres.

As Opportunity drove from the plains of Meridiani onto the rim of Endeavour Crater and Cape York, it crossed a geologic boundary and arrived at a much different and older region of ancient Mars.

The evidence for flowing liquid water at Endeavour crater is even more powerful than the silica deposits found by Spirit around the Home Plate volcanic feature at Gusev Crater a few years ago.

“We will look for more of these veins in the [Martian] springtime,” said Squyres.

If a bigger, fatter vein can be found, then Opportunity will be directed to grind into it with her still well functioning Rock Abrasion Tool, or RAT.

Homestake was crunched with the wheels – driving back and forth over the vein – to break it up and expose the interior. Opportunity did a triple crunch over Homestake, said Arvidson.

Homestake was found near the northern tip of Cape York, while Opportunity was scouting out a “Winter Haven” location to spend the approaching Martian winter.

Arvidson emphasized that the team wants Opportunity to be positioned on a northerly tilted slope to catch the maximum amount of the sun’s rays to keep the rover powered up for continuing science activities throughout the fast approaching Martian winter.

“Martian winter in the southern hemisphere starts on March 29, 2012. But, Solar power levels already begin dropping dramatically months before Martian winter starts,” said Alfonso Herrera to Universe Today, Herrera is a Mars rover mission manager at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena, Calif.

“Opportunity is in excellent health,” said Bruce Banerdt, the Project Scientist for the Mars rover mission at JPL.

“This has been a very exciting time. We’ll head back south in the springtime and have a whole bunch of things to do with a very capable robot,” Squyres concluded.

'Botany Bay' and 'Cape York' with Vertical Exaggeration
This graphic combines a perspective view of the "Botany Bay" and "Cape York" areas of the rim of Endeavour Crater on Mars, and an inset with mapping-spectrometer data. Major features are labeled. In the perspective view, the landscape's vertical dimension is exaggerated five-fold compared with horizontal dimensions. NASA's Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity examined targets in the Cape York area during the second half of 2011. The perspective view was generated by producing an elevation map from a stereo pair of images from the High Resolution Imaging Science Experiment (HiRISE) camera on NASA's Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, then draping one of the HiRISE images over the elevation model. The inset presents data from the Compact Reconnaissance Imaging Spectrometer for Mars (CRISM) instrument on the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter. In this CRISM observation, taken on March 29, 2011 Thermal inertia estimates from observations by the Thermal Emission Imaging System on NASA's Mars Odyssey orbiter indicate that Botany Bay is a region with extensive outcrop exposures. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/UA/JHUAPL

Meanwhile, NASA’s next leap in exploring potential Martian habitats for life – the car sized Curiosity Mars Science Lab rover – is speeding towards the Red Planet.

Read Ken’s continuing features about Opportunity starting here:

NASA Robot seeks Goldmine of Science and Sun at Martian Hill along vast Crater
Opportunity spotted Exploring vast Endeavour Crater from Mars Orbit
Twin Towers 9/11 Tribute by Opportunity Mars Rover
NASA Robot arrives at ‘New’ Landing Site holding Clues to Ancient Water Flow on Mars
Opportunity Arrives at Huge Martian Crater with Superb Science and Scenic Outlook
Opportunity Snaps Gorgeous Vistas nearing the Foothills of Giant Endeavour Crater

About 

Dr. Ken Kremer is a speaker, scientist, freelance science journalist (Princeton, NJ) and photographer whose articles, space exploration images and Mars mosaics have appeared in magazines, books, websites and calanders including Astronomy Picture of the Day, NBC, BBC, SPACE.com, Spaceflight Now and the covers of Aviation Week & Space Technology, Spaceflight and the Explorers Club magazines. Ken has presented at numerous educational institutions, civic & religious organizations, museums and astronomy clubs. Ken has reported first hand from the Kennedy Space Center, Cape Canaveral and NASA Wallops on over 40 launches including 8 shuttle launches. He lectures on both Human and Robotic spaceflight - www.kenkremer.com. Follow Ken on Facebook and Twitter

Comments on this entry are closed.

  • Anonymous December 11, 2011, 8:40 AM

    The relationship between Calcium Sulphate and water is complex. Gypsum has 2 molecules of water bound to the calcium sulphate. 75% of the water is driven off by heat to form Plaster of Paris represented by the formula CaSO4.1/2H2O. Calcium Sulphate also occurs on Earth in an anhydrous form – anhydrite.

    Are the team certain that what they are seeing in the dihdrate form?

    Brian
    Roseland Observatory.

  • Manjula Weerasinghe December 11, 2011, 12:05 PM

    They have finally found ruins of an ancient Martian building at last. See the second pic :D

    • Anonymous December 11, 2011, 2:05 PM

      No, that can’t possibly be since humans there disappeared many millions of years ago, at a time when there were oceans and a thicker atmosphere. There was a catastrophic climate change and eventually the roving sands covered everything. If they want to find any remains they’ll have to dig very deep trenches, not just scratch the surface with unsteady little robots. I assume that you’re not being sarcastic.

      As regards this I’m following one of my grandfather’s old Theosophy books, by a Mr. Leadbeater, who was a seer. There’s a big problem with his chronology, which is entirely erroneous, for reasons too involved to discuss in a scientific forum. I’m not monkeying around, either. I’m being earnest. I won’t be around anymore when evidence of this is finally unearthed (so to speak), maybe 50 to 100 years from now, so the laughing in the background will continue. You might want to visit the main headquarters of the Theosophical Society in Adyar, Madras.

      • Torbjörn Larsson December 11, 2011, 4:38 PM

        Don’t you think the more immediate problem is discussing religion such as theosophy on a science blog?

        • Anonymous December 11, 2011, 8:03 PM

          …but Theosophy is not a religion. Maybe the confusion is due to the fact that the name happens to be so similar to the word “theology”. It’s more like a scholarly endeavor one of whose purposes it is to make a comparative study of all religions, which is similar to what the science of sociology does. Anyway, I’m not in the process of preaching to the heathen. I don’t belong to any particular organization. In fact, I’d say that Theosophy is too tolerant of the three Abrahamic religions, which are quite disturbing (terrifying, in fact).

          • Torbjörn Larsson December 17, 2011, 1:57 PM

            Theosophy is religion, blatantly so.

            It was founded, as so many modern religions, by a scam artist that used religion and pseudoscience in order to make a living.

            Theosophy is based upon “the divine”.

          • Anonymous December 19, 2011, 7:11 PM

            Mme. Blavatsky has always been accused of being an impostor. You are making a selective use of the sources available, which is not surprising in a Dawkinsist. Dawkinsism itself is turning into a religion, in the sense that Marxism was described as being a religion, with its own prophets and orthodoxy and an intolerant attitude. Many outstanding, honest people have been either members of the Th. Society or have shown an interest in its teachings, like L. Frank Baum, author of THE WIZARD OF OZ, W.B. Yeats, the poet and playwright, Khalil Gibran, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the creator of Sherlock Holmes, Maurice Maeterlinck, who won the Nobel Prize for Literature, James Joyce, D.H. Lawrence (The Alexandria Quartet), Lewis Carroll (ALICE IN WONDERLAND), Flammarion, the astronomer, Wm. James, the philosopher and psychologist, C.G. Jung, the Swiss psychiatrist, Piet Mondriaan, the Dutch painter, Gauguin, Kandinsky, Maria Montessori, Mahler, Sibelius, Scriabin, Jane Goodall, the big ape ethologist, Edison, Sir Wm. Crookes, the physicist….

      • Anonymous December 12, 2011, 8:58 AM

        Theosophy?
        Seers?
        Humans on Mars?

        Um – this is a science blog. Since you have zero evidence to back your rather wild claims, you’d probably be best to take these ideas off to another forum. They’ll gain zero traction here.

        • Anonymous December 13, 2011, 10:59 AM

          True, my comments do seem to be out of place here, but not entirely. After all, it was someone else who decided to mention ruins in Mars, in a derogatory, challenging way that was asking for a reaction.

          It’s no wonder that the subject is laughable. Some people claim that ruins can be seen in certain photographs. As I said, whatever remains there are, whether natural or artificial, must be under tons of soil, not lying around for the taking. My purpose was to remind others that clairvoyance is not necessarily something linked to psychotic personalities and that there is an old (est. 1875) organization that has something to say on the matter. Additionally, I wanted to know whether or not the author of the comment is one of those thoroughly westernized, thoroughly “modern” contemporaries who are traitors to their own culture. If he applies hit-and-run tactics then we can’t expect a reply.

          Ancient Martians or not, what we need on Mars is a big, simple, sturdy BULLDOZER that can search for possible macrofossils, not weak contraptions with complex minilabs that claw the soil like a chicken, looking, not even for tiny seeds to swallow, but for germs. Even the possible germs must be deep down (or in caves), out of harm’s way (deadly radiation, desiccation away from the poles). I don’t know if a bulldozer can be sent in a single trip, but if not, then they can easily send it on four or five spaceships and assemble it on arrival.

          They’ve been doing it for almost half a century now with negative results. It’s not working, so the time has come to try something else. I’ve grown desperate because I’ve had to put up with it ever since my school days, and I’m almost sixty. My project agrees with the new faster-better-cheaper policy tha the NASA has adopted.

          If there’s to be a breakthrough before I die, someone will have to convince them that they’ve been fooling around far too long. It will have to be someone with the initials “Ph.D.” after his/her name. They don’t pay any attention to suggestions made by amateurs. So, are you scholarly enough to do us all the big favor? If so then, Dr. Astrofiend, I thank you in advance.

          • Torbjörn Larsson December 17, 2011, 2:00 PM

            Of course ruins is mentioned in a derogatory, challenging way. How else, since we now know that there can’t be any? Mars history precludes the necessary productive biosphere.

          • Anonymous December 19, 2011, 7:10 PM

            Reading my comment more carefully will show that I mention the possibility of there having been a very different environment millions, and maybe even hundreds of millions of years ago, as present planetary science believes, at a time when there was water on the surface and maybe a much thicker atmosphere. Nowhere was it claimed that that there could’ve been macrolife forms in the recent past.

  • Torbjörn Larsson December 11, 2011, 4:30 PM

    The good news could be that they found calcium and its salts, presumably indicating alkaline water.

    That stands to reason I think. The modern acidic surface conditions may derive from imbalances of atmospheric loss. But the CO2 primordial atmosphere indicates the near neutral state that at least Earth seems to have started out from. If life got started on Earth under near neutral conditions, so could it do on Mars. And if the crust is less acidic below, we have a good case for still benign conditions and, if there is still thermal energy around, potential presence of local redox cells from circulating hot water providing energy for any existing life.

    So we have evidence of neutralization. Gypsum seems to be a controversial substance as regards soil properties. The positive picture of soil conditioner in Wikipedia is disclaimed by other material that speaks of “myths”.

    What the sources seem to agree on, directly or indirectly, is that gypsum doesn’t make much as a pH regulator. However, it may benefit saline soils, so at a guess its water activity, its ability to take up water, is fairly low in comparison with other salts. Indeed, briansheen’s comment below indicates the same I think, the amount of crystalline water uptake is low for a salt.

    So an indirect boon to habitability besides proving the presence of calcium.

  • Anonymous December 11, 2011, 9:51 PM

    Ken Kremer wrote a guest post for Lofty Ambitions about the Mars rovers, after we met him at Kennedy Space Center. It’s great to see his work here at Universe Today and to see the work he’s doing with both science writing and photography.

    Here’s his other Lofty piece for those interested: http://loftyambitions.wordpress.com/2011/04/18/guest-blog-ken-kremer/.

hide