Lightning Storms on Venus Similar to Those On Earth

by Nancy Atkinson on September 22, 2010

Want to stay on top of all the space news? Follow @universetoday on Twitter

Artists impression of lightning storms on Venus. Credit: ESA

Venus is a world not for the faint of heart. On its surface you’d have to endure high temperatures and intense air pressures, plus within the thick, sulfuric acid-laced atmosphere there are actually lightning storms. These storms are surprisingly similar to lightning storms on Earth, despite the great differences between the atmospheres of the two planets. “Venus and Earth are often called twin planets because of their similar size, mass, and interior structure,” said Dr. Christopher Russell from the University of California, who presented his findings at the European Planetary Science Congress in Rome this week. “The generation of lightning is one more way in which Venus and Earth are fraternal twins.”

Scientists have known there was lightning on Venus since the early planetary missions such as the Venera and Pioneer Venus Orbiter missions, and more recently the Galileo spacecraft reported evidence for optical and electromagnetic waves from Venus that could be produced by lightning. This was also confirmed by ground telescopes capturing lighting flashes at Venus.

Now, the Venus Express spacecraft, in orbit around Venus, has been studying Venus’ lightning in detail with its magnetometer, looking at the rates of discharge, the intensity and the spatial distribution in the magnetic field at altitudes between 200 and 500 km.

Russell said the Venus electromagnetic signals associated with lightning discharges are stronger than terrestrial signals in this frequency band because the background magnetic field is much weaker and the waves travel more slowly, but the electromagnetic energy flux is similar to that on Earth.

“Short strong pulses of the signals expected to be produced by lightning were seen almost immediately upon arrival at Venus, despite the generally unfavorable magnetic field orientation for entry of the signals into the Venus ionosphere at the altitude of the Venus Express measurements,” said Russell.

The observed electromagnetic waves are strongly guided by the Venusian magnetic field and they can only be detected by the spacecraft when the magnetic field tilts away from the horizontal by more than 15 degrees. This is quite unlike the situation on Earth, where the lightning signals are aided in their entry into the ionosphere by the nearly vertical magnetic field.

When clouds form, on Earth or Venus, the energy that the Sun has deposited in the air can be released in a very powerful electrical discharge. As cloud particles collide, they transfer electrical charge from large particles to small, and the large particles fall while the small particles are carried upward. The separation of charges leads to lightning strokes. This process is important for a planetary atmosphere because it raises the temperature and pressure of a small portion of the atmosphere to a very high value so that molecules can form, which would not otherwise occur at standard atmospheric temperatures and pressures. This is why some scientists have speculated that lightning may have helped life to arise on Earth.

“We have analyzed 3.5 Earth-years of Venus lightning data using the low-altitude Venus Express data, which is about 10 minutes per day,” Russell said. “By comparing the electromagnetic waves produced at the two planets, we found stronger magnetic signals on Venus, but when converted to energy flux we found very similar lightening strength,” said Russell. Also it seems that lightning is more prevalent on the dayside than at night, and happens more often at low Venusian latitudes where the solar input to the atmosphere is strongest.”

Source: European Planetary Science Congress

About 

Nancy Atkinson is Universe Today's Senior Editor. She also is the host of the NASA Lunar Science Institute podcast and works with Astronomy Cast. Nancy is also a NASA/JPL Solar System Ambassador.

Aqua September 22, 2010 at 4:32 PM

Fascinating! Especially the part about “…the magnetic field tilts away from the horizontal by more than 15 degrees…” Hmmm… I thought Venus didn’t have a mag. field? Then I read the following: http://www-ssc.igpp.ucla.edu/personnel/russell/papers/venus_mag/

Torbjorn Larsson OM September 22, 2010 at 7:41 PM

A lightning post to follow up on the lightning speed of the new servers?

Actually I would say no surprise, since dense and energetic atmospheres seems conducive to lightning (compare the gas giants and their heavy lightning), though a nice test. And since charge separation and lightning is rather poorly understood from volcanism induced to cloud induced, I assume it will be good to have a nearby differential example.

I thought Venus didn’t have a mag. field?

All solid bodies may have remnant fields, and atmospheric planets have induced fields; your link is a good reference on what AFAIK we see on Mars, Titan, et cetera. Strong dynamo fields (Earth et cetera) is a game changer on that background.

SteveZodiac September 23, 2010 at 9:15 AM

It was a dark and stormy 5832 hour night…….

Lawrence B. Crowell September 24, 2010 at 3:52 AM

The phenomenon of lightning formation is actually not well known. The theory is that phase transitions from gas to liquid in clouds leads to electric charge. On Earth this is due to water condensation that forms rain and on Venus this is due to sulfuric acid rain. The idea, as indicated in Atkinson’s article, is that droplets flying around collide with friction and this generates a charge, and larger falling droplets will leave a charge they deposit on smaller droplet particles. The presumed mechanism is then not that different from rubbing an animal fur on a rod, or one’s shoes across carpet to set up a charge. However, we actually have no idea why this should result in a charge separation. It is a bit of an oddity, but for all our advances in physics this little mechanism is not that well understood, but is widely invoked.

Venus has no magnetic field presumably because it has a very slow rate of rotation. However, a lightning discharge is a current and this is associated with a magnetic field. Further, since the current varies with time this magnetic field varies and by Maxwell’s equations is associated with a changing electric field. This variable electric and magnetic field occurs as a wave that propagates out. The Venus Express spacecraft from its in orbit of Venus can detect these EM waves. It really is not that different from the an AM radio tuner picking up static with lightning discharges.

I read last month an article on using silicon carbide as a substrate for computer chips. What was interesting is this operates optimally at temperatures around 500K, which is not substantially that cooler than temperatures on Venus. I mention this because there have been discussions about what it might take to put a rover on the Venus surface. This looks like one small step in that directions.

LC

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: