Arizona Scientist: We Could All Be Martians

by Anne Minard on February 21, 2009

Artist's conception of an fragment as it blasts off from Mars. Boulder-sized planetary fragments could be a mechanism that carried life between Mars and Earth, UA planetary scientist Jay Melosh says. (Credit: The Planetary Society)

Artist's conception of an fragment as it blasts off from Mars. Boulder-sized planetary fragments could be a mechanism that carried life between Mars and Earth, UA planetary scientist Jay Melosh says. (Painting by Don Davis. Copyright SETI Institute, 1994)

As long as we’re still pondering human origins, we may as well entertain the idea that our ancestor microbes came from Mars.

And Jay Melosh, a planetary scientist from the University of Arizona in Tucson, is ready with a geologically plausible explanation.

Meteorites.

“Biological exchange between the planets of our solar system seem not only possible, but inevitable,” because of meteorite exchanges between the planets, Melosh said. “Life could have originated on the planet Mars and then traveled to Earth.”

jay_melosh

Jay Melosh. Credit: Maria Schuchardt, University of Arizona Lunar and Planetary Lab

Melosh is a long-time researcher who says he’s studied “geological violence in all its forms.” He helped forge the giant impact theory of the moon’s formation, and helped advance the theory that an impact led to the extinction of the dinosaurs 65 million years ago.

He points out that Martian meteorites have been routinely pummeling Earth for billions of years, which would have opened the door for past Mars microbes to hitch a ride. Less regularly, Earth has undergone impacts that sent terrestrial materials flying, and some of those could have carried microbes toward the Red Planet.

“The mechanism by which large impacts on Mars can launch boulder-sized surface rocks into space is now clear,” he said. He explained that a shock wave spreads away from an impact site faster than the speed of sound, interacting with the planetary surface in a way that allows material to be cast off – at relatively low pressure, but high speed.

“Lightly damaged material at very high speeds,” he said, “is the kind of environment where microorganisms can survive.”

Scientists have recent evidence of Earth microbes surviving a few years in space. When the Apollo 12 astronauts landed on the moon, they retrieved a camera from Surveyor 3, an unmanned lander that had touched down nearly three years prior. Earthly microbes – including those associated with the common cold — were still living inside the camera box.

“The records were good enough to show one of the technicians had a cold when he was working on it,” he said.

Scientists also have evidence that microbes can survive for thousands or even hundreds of thousands of years when frozen on Earth, but surviving that long in space would be an entirely different matter, with the bombardment of UV light and cosmic rays. Then again, the microbe Dienococcus radiodurans is known to survive in the cores of nuclear reactors.

Melosh acknowledges that scientists lack proof that such an exchange has actually occurred between Mars and Earth — but science is getting ever closer to being able to track it down. 

LEAD PHOTO CAPTION: Artist’s conception of an fragment as it blasts off from Mars. Boulder-sized planetary fragments could be a mechanism that carried life between Mars and Earth, UA planetary scientist Jay Melosh says. (Painting by Don Davis. Copyright SETI Institute, 1994)

Source: University of Arizona and an interview with Jay Melosh

  • dollhopf

    If life once came from Mars then life should also try all the day long to spread itself from earth! From earth, across all the rest of the solar system. All the day!

    Mars should once have been a fertile place for genetic material, if the rare events of ejection with escape velocity might have transported “sources of infection” not only into interplanetary space, but also to a tiny spot named Earth, injecting Earth with fertile instead of futile rocky bio-carriers.

    Therefore, if the panspermia theory holds true, we should on the other hand also detect frutile material from earth in every corner of this solar system.

    “Our” microbes should also be “outdoors”, if the theory of life from Mars holds true!

  • Bravehart

    It is common knowledge that our geninome
    is not pure? By now we have established,
    that our genome is an mix, ergo this manipulation of the genome code must have been done by a superior induvidual, which we
    currently have no knowledge of! The question
    really is, WHO did had that knowledge to create a HUMAN? At least that is what we call our self? We are at this point, that we are comparing the “HUMAN” genome with that of
    other spiecy’s on this planet and early indications are that we are related with them
    on the genome level? So what does all this means? Well my thought’s are that it was not an accident nor an random act it is to complicated for either one! That leaves us
    with the possibility that we had visitors?
    There are faint records of that possibility, but
    even if, the immensity of manupilation of tempering with so many genome varriaties is
    mind blowing and the fact that it took some
    generations to develop which implicate that
    the visitors must had an long life and stayed
    a while? If we consider that a “HUMAN” is a
    “near” perfect chemical factory, ask any doctor
    how well this self sustainable factory of a human body is and so I still have a hard time
    in believing that it was an accident? Ergo this
    leaves the possibility of creation to a likeness
    of a being but where did they came from and
    why us? Darwin has stated the obvious because it is in the code of the genome, all
    live formes are coded to develope albeit each
    in its own way including “HUMANS”

  • http://oilismastery.blogspot.com/ OilIsMastery

    Yes it’s possible although there is no evidence for it, scientific or otherwise.

    But science isn’t about possibility.

    Imagination is about possibility; science is about what is.

    It’s also possible that Venus was a comet Phaeton that disturbed the orbits of the solar system and caused a catastrophic meteor shower, conflagration, and deluge but saying so causes fundamentalists to start drooling and frothing at the mouth.

  • Alex

    Blah.. ‘Scientists” have been saying this for decades…

  • Essel

    Genetic code is extremely complex and comprehensive and must have taken considerable time to evolve. It might have evolved prior to the origin of the solar system itself. As the solar system has been gifted with the wide range of elements in the periodic table other than Hydrogen and Helium in the core of our star, the basic signature of life may also have been similarly gifted to us.

    Biological exchange between not only planets but between various past and present star systems is very much probable.

    The extent of development of life probably depends upon the environment that the genetic code finds itself in. By this logic Earth is the most likely candidate in the solar system to have captured and propagated this code rather than receiving it through other planets in the solar system.

    However, this guess is on the basis of what we are seeing today. Perhaps the conditions might have been more conducive on Mars and even on Venus compared to Earth in the distant past. It is probable that life might have taken a root in these places and then found a better environment to thrive on Earth.

    It is less probable to imagine that life originated from scratch on Mars and then came to Earth.

    In the future when a catastrophe strikes planet Earth it is possible that a good chunk of bacterial life with the genetic code shall be ejected out into interplanetary or even interstellar space. The bigger the impact the more distance it will travel taking the genetic code to safety. For a small impact some of these chunks of rock will fall back to the Earth itself bringing back the seeds of life to flourish again after the bad times are over. When the impact is so big that the life cannot flourish again, the rocks would have momentum to leave the solar system and try to hunt another place to settle!

  • huygens

    Anne, here are the two paragraphs in question. The first one says scientists did find microbes in the lunar lander robot that had been on the Moon for over 2 years. The second one quotes Melosh saying otherwise it was someone examining the Surveyor 3 equipment after the Apollo 12 mission who accidentally put the bugs there.

    You tell me how I am to interepret this:

    Surveyor 3, an unmanned lander that had touched down nearly three years prior. Earthly microbes – including those associated with the common cold — were still living inside the camera box.

    “The records were good enough to show one of the technicians had a cold when he was working on it,” he [Melosh] said.

  • LLDIAZ

    why is it always Mars?
    We couldn’t have come from somewhere else?
    Somewhere deeper in space..

  • ND

    Mars is the closest body with the most potential to have had life. It’s about the chances of material exchange based on what we know so far about our solar system. I don’t think anything has been ruled out. Comets and other bodies from the edges of the solar system are thought to be potential sources of biological building blocks.

  • Olaf

    Bravehart – “It is common knowledge that our geninome
    is not pure? By now we have established,
    that our genome is an mix, ergo this manipulation of the genome code must have been done by a superior induvidual, which we
    currently have no knowledge of!”

    According to percisely who us this common knowledge?
    And How do you know that this common knowledge is actually true?

  • watchful stone guardian

    “# LLDIAZ Says:
    February 23rd, 2009 at 9:15 am

    why is it always Mars?
    We couldn’t have come from somewhere else?
    Somewhere deeper in space..”

    I agree. Why not Martian microbes coming from Terrestrial or Venusian origins. Venus was warmer and likely had global oceans; add in a huge volcano from Aphrodite Terra and “ka-pow” life springs into existence on Venus…. not that I’m actually seriously suggesting this scenario.

    I suspect that Terrestrial life popped into existence right here on Terra Firma (Terra Aqua?) and has been multiplying and mutating away for æons.

  • Mike

    I’m still convinced that Zecharia Sitchin’s ideas are the closet to the truth. It just makes good sense. :)

  • http://anneminard.com Anne Minard

    Huygens:

    evidence … surviving a few years in space … three years prior … still living

    All terms suggesting that the microbes had survived a few years in space and were still living when the camera was inspected. I’m sorry you’ve had so much trouble with those two paragraphs, and I hope this helps.

  • Spoodle58

    I think the jest of what Jay Melosh is saying is that we could be from another planetary body, I think we all could say that is possible, but we need to research this more.

    I think the planetary society are testing this theory out in an upcoming launch to Phobos.

    As Alex was saying that this is not old news, sure that is correct and it just goes to show you that ALH84001 may indeed harbour fossilized proto-bacteria, all in all this is exciting stuff.

  • http://www.astronomija.com.mk Mile Naskovski

    That’s on BIG “Could”

    We could be Crabpeople as well, but it’s another “could”

  • Dark Gnat

    So, life, water and everything else seems to have come from somewhere else.

    Why are these people refusing to accept the possibility that water, carbon and the other elements required for life existed on earth from its formation?

  • William

    I am convinced that Zecharia Sitchen is a well paid disinformation agent working for the House of Rothschild to deflect any investigation into the fiction that Moses led slaves out of Egypt and that the AskeNAZI brach of Judaism are not Semitic! Sitchen would want you to think that the reason for the looting of the Bagdad Museum was to cover up the Annunaki “creation”, but it seems more likely that there was much proof that the Old Testament was a mixing of Egyptian and Babylonian mythologies.

  • Mr. Bad Joke

    No, not Mars, Kobol. And we’re ALL Cylons BTW. Not Human.

  • Peter

    By your command, BJ!

    Earth has so many fabulous and varied ecosystems, harbouring every kind of life. We still have NO idea how life began but have proven that in almost any environment, the basic building blocks of life assemble almost automatically. (nice to hear for people who like a little company in the cosmos!) So as long as that first spark was here, and lord (small L) knows, we gots lots of sparks, then for absolutely sure, our earth would have made the most out of that possibility and encouraged the flourishing and abundance we see today. No need for extraterrestrial help, No need for meteorites and seeding. Life is here. Life did not start as an intelligent alien, but fossil records show that it started very modestly. That would indicate it started here, as a very basic model. That’s why every bacteria is my buddy.

  • TD

    Peter – a fossil record of very basic life forms is also consistent with life on Earth being the result of bacteria that have been delivered here through space, either by a meteor or some other method. And watching the basic building blocks (amino acids) assemble from the right ingredients (like Urey did 50 years ago) is light years away from having a reproducing life form self assemble. Science hasn’t even gotten close to figuring out how this could happen. So did it take millions of years, or billions of years, for life to form? If the answer is billions, then the fossil record shows there wasn’t time on Earth – so it happened someplace else. And can bacteria survive space? Not all – but it only takes one bacteria to start life on a planet. Scientists have got to have open minds when considering this question.

  • RUF

    The earlier Edicarian Biota may (repeat may) show that evolution started twice on the Earth. This biota pre-dated the Cambrian explosion, and has no direct lineage to life forms today.

    Or, Maybe Edicarian biology was the “original” life on Earth until it was displaced by Martian lifeforms creating the Cambrian Explosion 542 Mya.

Previous post:

Next post: